The shame on K2 | Documentary film

The drone footage went around the world: around 80 summiteers were shotรŸen the seriously injured Pakistani high porter Muhammad Hassan at approx. 8.200 meters to reach the summit of K2. How could this happen? Servus TV will investigate this question in the program โ€œThe Shame on K2โ€ on October 2, 2023.

The drone footage went around the world: A team from Servus-TV was on site on July 27, 2023 when around 80 summiteers left the seriously injured Pakistani porter Muhammad Hassan at around 8.200 meters in order to reach the summit of K2. How could this happen?

High porter Muhammad Hassan is not helped
Summiteers climb over the injured Muhammad Hassan without helping. (Image Hello TV)

On July 27, 2023, more people than ever before gathered at the K2 base camp, far in the north of Pakistan and right on the border with China, to climb the second highest mountain in the world at 8.611 meters. Many of them were clients of expedition providers with little mountain or altitude experience who offer this dangerous mountain to their customers in so-called tourist climbs. Such expeditions are only possible for these โ€œhigh-altitude touristsโ€ with intensive use of additional oxygen and on secured routes. This requires a large number of workers who are suitable for altitudes, who bring the oxygen bottles up the mountain, deposit them in high camps and provide the ascent route with fixed ropes on which the paying customers climb towards the summit like a via ferrata. 

Trailer for the show โ€œThe Shame of K2โ€

Cheap labor for western expedition guests

Pakistani high-altitude porters hired by expedition agencies often have little mountaineering experience and little knowledge of alpine safety techniques. Nevertheless, they are usually just as capable of high altitudes as the famous Sherpas from Nepal. Above all, they are cheap workers due to the great poverty in Pakistan's Karakoram regions. Muhammad Hassan, who died on K27 on July 2023, 2, was one of these high porters. He brought the fixed ropes up to 8.200 meters, where they were to be attached to the โ€œbottleneckโ€. Whether due to a slab of snow or a misstep, Muhammad Hassan slipped and got stuck upside down on the rope. When he fell, his oxygen mask broke and some of his clothing was torn off. The unprofessional rescue operation lasted hours and was made more difficult by dozens of summiteers pushing past. Muhammad Hassan died on the morning of July 27th.

Mass tourism on K2. (Image mountain worlds)
Mass tourism on K2. (Photo Philip Flรคmig / ServusTV)

High-altitude tourists without compassion?

Never before has an Alpine emergency situation at extreme altitudes been documented as well in images as the consequences of the accident at 8.200 meters. The details only came to light through the drone footage taken by the ServusTV team and through an investigative commission run by the Pakistani government. They document the selfish and cynical actions of many mountaineers in this situation. At the same time, the mountaineering inability of many summiteers leaves you speechless. They are either on the hunt for records or as clients of the major expedition operators as pure high-altitude tourists on the highest mountains in the world and have neither mastered alpine rope nor rescue techniques. For some people, any form of empathy or mountaineering ethics seems alien.

The base camp on K2. (Image mountain worlds)
The base camp on K2. (Image Hello TV)

In addition to successful high-altitude mountaineers such as Gerlinde Kaltenbrunner and Hans Kammerlander, the Brazilian cameraman Gabriel Tarso, who tried to help Muhammad Hassan on the spot, and the Tyrolean hotelier and mountaineer Willi Steindl, who after the accident, also have their say in the โ€œBergweltenโ€ documentary visited Hassan's family and started a fundraiser for his wife and children. The ServusTV team also spoke to the Pakistani liaison officers and the Tyrolean alpinist Lukas Wรถrle, who just a week earlier on the neighboring Broad Peak saved the life of a mountain porter suffering from altitude sickness by bringing him from 8.000 meters into the valley and thereby putting aside his own summit ambitions .

When will the show air?

The program โ€œMountain Worldsโ€ will be broadcast live on Monday, October 2, 2023 from 20:15 p.m. Following the documentary, a โ€œSport and Talk from the Hangar-21 Specialโ€ will be dedicated to these tragic events on K10 from 7:2 p.m., including Hans Kammerlander, Sabrina Filmoser and Willi Steindl. 

That might interest you

Do you like our climbing magazine? When launching the climbing magazine Lacrux, we decided not to introduce a paywall because we want to provide as many like-minded people as possible with news from the climbing scene.

In order to be more independent of advertising revenue in the future and to provide you with even more and better content, we need your support.

Therefore: Help and support our magazine with a small contribution. Naturally you benefit multiple times. How? You will find out here..

+ + +
Credits: Pictures Servus TV

News

Caroline Ciavaldini is the third woman to climb the crack testpiece Greenspit (8b/+)

On Sunday, November 3, French climber Caroline...

First ascent of the southwest ridge of the 6000er Bhagirathi III

On October 8, 2024, Jonas Schild, Stephan Siegrist,...

Babsi Zangerl climbs one of the hardest crack routes in the world: Magic Line (8c+)

Babsi Zangerl repeats a tough climb with Magic Line (8c+)...

Schubert and Pilz climb to victory in record time | Red Bull Dual Ascent

Jessica Pilz and Jakob Schubert won the Red Bull Dual Ascent 2024 with ease. Here are the pictures and the video replay.

Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter now and stay up to date.

Caroline Ciavaldini is the third woman to climb the crack testpiece Greenspit (8b/+)

On Sunday, November 3, French climber Caroline Ciavaldini repeated the route Greenspit (8b/+) in Valle dell'Orco, Italy. She is only the third woman to...

First ascent of the southwest ridge of the 6000er Bhagirathi III

On October 8, 2024, Jonas Schild, Stephan Siegrist, Kaspar Grossniklaus and Hugo Beguin mastered what was probably the first ascent of the southwest ridge of the six-thousand-meter peak Bhagirathi III...

Babsi Zangerl climbs one of the hardest crack routes in the world: Magic Line (8c+)

Babsi Zangerl repeats a rock-hard trad line in Yosemite Valley with Magic Line (8c+). After Hazel Findlay, she is only the second woman to do this...